Focusing until it hurts doesn’t work with meditation. Yet, I understand people want feedback in their meditation practice.
Have you heard that phrase, “Focus until it hurts?” Focusing until it hurts on purpose is a bad move.
If you try to focus too hard, you’ll just end up giving yourself a headache. It’s not sustainable. It’s better to just gently apply your focus on something and keep coming back to it when you’ve lost focus. It’s the Flow Like Water finger in my Five Fingers of Freedom.
What other feedback options exist? Have you heard of brain signal reading headbands like Muse? Muse is touted as a “brain sensing headband” that makes meditating easy.
There are reviews like the Wearable Review that almost got me buying it. There are also videos like the Muse Brain Sensing Headband from TechCrunch:
From the how does muse work page,
Muse gives you feedback about your meditation in real time by translating your brain signals into the sounds of wind.
So, it sounds great. However, I am concerned about the potential set up for a longterm failure. Before I go into that, I need to share my respect for what they are trying to do with Muse.
In that video above, we see CEO and Founder of InteraXon, Ariel Garten. I respect Ariel Garten’s mission and have followed the company’s journey for over five years. As Ariel said in a Ted Talk titled Know thyself, with a brain scanner:
My goal, quite simply, is to help people become more in tune with themselves.
Although I have seriously considered buying Muse, real time feedback sounds like it could potentially encourage what is known as wrong effort. A strong desire to get results immediately generates an energy that is counter productive.
Wrong Effort By George Mumford
About fourteen minutes into the session titled “Change the Mindset” of the 10% Happier: Meditation for Fidgety Skeptics meditation app, George Mumford captures the concept of trying too hard and over-monitoring well:
When that energy is driving you to the point to where you’re always looking to see how you’re doing, you’re not present to what you are doing.
As a side note, George Mumford impresses me so much! The 10% Happier app has really helped distilled his concepts into a concise format. To get access to the concepts, you need to get the 10% Happier app and then subscribe to get past the free introduction material. I’m a huge fan.
If you want to read something instead, you can get the book George co-authored called The Mindful Athlete: Secrets to Pure Performance. Another option is that I cover George’s concept of how negative self talk feeds the “fear wolf” in Lose Negative Self Talk By Losing Yourself.
Is Realtime Feedback Useful?
Although I haven’t purchased Muse and seen for myself, I haven’t decided if using Muse is a good idea or not. It didn’t help that Arial said in the Muse Brain Sensing Headband video above:
And it’s your job to quiet the wind and quiet the mind.
When you’re mind is distracted while wearing Muse, you receive the noise of wind. Well, trying to quiet the mind head-on seems incorrect. As a meditator, your job is to observe your thoughts. It’s not to force your thoughts to go away. However, it’s possible she has to say something like that in order for people to frame the conversation quickly in their minds.
As I wrote in Meditation Journey is Simple, you don’t want to force your attention on the breath. You want to just notice that you’ve lost your focus and begin again. Recognizing you’re lost and beginning again builds up the mental focus muscle.
Listening further, I can tell she correctly understands the overall concept. She then says something interesting I had not considered before. In the context of a mental fitness gym, using Muse is where:
You get to do more reps in a single session.
That sounds very compelling. However, there is still a question here. Specifically, which part exercises ones mental focus? Is it the recognition that you’re lost in thought or the act of bringing your focus back on to the object? In other words, is it recognition or refocusing that makes your ability to focus stronger?
Where to Find The Answer?
It’s at this point where I feel fortunate that I have the 10% Happier app. I can literally send a text message to my coach in the 10% Happier app and see what they say. In fairness, they may not know because without Muse or a product like it, one recognizes they are lost in thought and brings their focus back onto the object of focus. Therefore, one is doing both activities of recognizing and refocusing. So, it wouldn’t be a burning question for those who don’t use brain reading headbands.
Although the name escapes me, there is also someone in the 10% Happier podcast that Dan interviewed who might know the answer. Unless you know of other possible sources, I am left with nothing else other than googling for the answer.
Applying This For Work
Having clear answers as to what really works is essential. Forward thinking companies are always looking for ways to increase the production capabilities of its employees. My positive experiences from working at CARFAX such as when they helped pay for a Fitbit, gives me hope that in the long run companies will support employees going after the benefits of meditation / mental-focus exercising.
However, a tool like Muse can’t be recommended until benefits are clear. Until then, recommending an app like the 10% Happier meditation app is a safe and enjoyable solution.
4 thoughts on “Meditation Brain Headbands And Wrong Effort”
Are you critiquing a product you’ve never tried on theory? 🤨 …you are indeed courageous 🤝
I’m a total wimp though…🖐🏻😬 I’d be checking my assumptions… I mean…what if I just ignored the Musewind, and meditated as usual, and maybe even visualizing an outdoor setting…and let the Muse speak to my unconscious?
Yes. Great question and thoughts, Yuri. Thank you for your kind words.
I am happy to check my assumptions and try out the product. As you know, checking your assumptions is wise. There is also wisdom in consulting with experts. Experts are not perfect, but are more likely to be right than wrong about their area of expertise.
Whether I try out the product or not, there is some fundamental guidance that is needed. The right tool with the wrong guidance is (at best) wasteful. At its worst, years are lost as one is traveling down the wrong trajectory. The ah-hah moments of finally “getting it” aka enlightenment are preceded by confusion and delusion.
I have seen and see people who are off-course a few degrees. Without slight course corrections, they sometimes veer way off and take others with them who are following them.
An instruction like “And it’s your job to quiet the wind and quiet the mind.” can be misleading. Let the meditator beware.
I got a muse 2 weeks ago and was really happy at first, but I don’t think it really reads the mind correctly. I think feedback is always useful, but there is lagging and soon Ii think I’ll get tired of the wind picking up just as I’m starting to relax again after a focus wobble. Cheers, Joe from BrainHive
That’s good to know, Joe. Thanks for the feedback about Muse. I value the wisdom in what you are saying. In other words, who wants a double whammy of distraction as soon as his or her focus wobbles? Great point!